G4POP wrote: 25 Oct 2020, 11:12
It is a well know fact in graphic interface circles that the human eye scans top left to top right and then diagonally down to the lower left corner before moving across to the lower right corner of screens, leaflets, newspapers etc etc (Some countries in the middle east are of course the opposite)
That is why the input fields are placed where they are
You could of course reduce the window size to that of Win4Icom suite and possition at the bottom just like Win4Icom suite!
Or do as suggested and use the contest or winkeyer windows as below, the options are varied but I dont see a reason to rewrite the UI?
I respectfully disagree with the "well known fact" in this case.
If I am reading a document, I would agree with your "well known" fact, but if I am entering data, I want the "entry field" to be center screen, at eye level. Since our logger screen is almost always mounted above our radio, the upper left data entry box is almost the worst possible place, since it causes us to take our eyes from the radio and crane our neck awkwardly.
Now then..... the idea of using the Contest Entry or WinKey forms and position them in lower center screen makes a LOT of sense. Below is how that looks at my station. (This is a 2-monitor arrangement. The left screen is centered above my radio.)
The right half is the familiar Log4OM main screen, set up to provide me with information about the contact. On the left side I have positioned the WinKey window in the perfectly IDEAL spot for data entry, directly above my radio. Just a minor shift of my eyes takes me from the radio to the data entry window.
So the problem would seem to be solved, right?
Unhappily, NOT.
While the data entry point is now EXACTLY where it ought be, the information being entered is not linked to the main screen on the right.
Note in my screen grab, I have entered the call of K7SS in the WinKey window. But the main screen on the right reflects information from a previous QSO on a different mode.
Ideally, when I enter a call in the "WinKey" window, the "main" screen at right should behave as if I had entered that call over there. (The "contest" entry window has the same behaviour)
In short.....
1) The "upper left" data entry point sucks ergonomically.
2) Using the alternate "contest" or "winkey" data entry, while ergonomically perfect, fails because the main screen doesn't follow/react to the data being entered at the WinKey window.
